best amish restaurants in ohio

Please contact me on email or at 513 208 8385. Website. Just be ready for the rooster to crow tomorrow at dawn. Its not a fancy affair. The roast beef is like no other roast beef Ive ever tasted, and the dressing is made with a cornbread base. Gastoff Amish Village: Located in Daviess County, Indiana, this Amish-themed village is home to a great restaurant full of homemade bread, soups, and pastries. Check out my list of things to do in Millersburg, Ohio. 22611 Ohio 2 Serving guests for more than 40 years, Amish Door Restaurant provides breakfast, lunch and dinner for up to 450 visitors each day, Monday through Saturday. Restaurants near Amish Country, Ohio on TripAdvisor: Find traveler reviews and candid photos of dining near Amish Country in Ohio, United States. Best amish restaurant near me in Columbus, OH Sort:Recommended Price 1. Salads are always fresh and cold. Another restaurant right down the road is the Penn Alps. Attlee grows his own green beans, potatoes, onions, garlic, zucchini, and tomatoes and sells local berries, corn, peaches . Hershberger's Farm and Bakery 543 reviews Closed today Dessert, American $ "Great Place to shop and go for a Buggy." "Great place to visit!" 3. Thank you! Make Memories, One Cool Family Outing at a Time! And dont plan to need to eat the rest of the day. Bolivar, OH Its sort of a sport but not quite, at least in my thinking (hey, any game where you can wear baggy pants as a uniform, chew tobacco, and sport a belly, but still manage to competethere is something different there than what you see from the typical athlete in most other sports). 29683 Walhonding Road No one can run on empty. This Stunning Lodge Offers An Affordable, Resort-Level Getaway In One Of Ohios Most Beautiful State Parks, Youll Swear Youre Dining In A European Bistro When You Visit This Cafe In Small Town Ohio, The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, 12 Hidden Gems Along The Ohio Countryside That Are So Worth The Drive, The Awesome Store Every Ohioan Should Tour At Least Once, Why People Go Crazy For This One Pie In Small Town Ohio, The Gigantic Fruit Spread Store In Ohio Youll Want To Visit Over And Over Again, unique hardware store in the middle of nowhere, Tis The Season Christmas Shoppe in Millersburg, this road trip to the best Amish country stores. They also had an ice cream counter, where the Amish young people were stopping in , to buy a cone or treat. Who knew? Menus are planned daily to take advantage of the finest produce, meat, and fish available in the area! Building was torn down, I believe in prep for the new fire station. amishdoor.com 6005 County Road 77, Millersburg, OH 44654 So if you want a place where Amish frequent often, Id stick with Mrs. Yoders . Why choose fast food with all that good Swiss fare around? Their butter cheese is amazing! On a previous post I was lightly chastised for eating at Subway while in the Berne Amish settlement. Maybe theyll add a stack of buckwheat pancakes and bacon just to keep the company a little longer. Theres space for games and conversation. The restaurant is open Monday-Saturday from 7 am- 8 pm. It just struck me funny because you usually hear of such things taking place at their homes with family and friends not in a public place like this, you know? Website. Amish-style food abounds in Ohio, especially in the tourist-friendly Holmes County community, with over a dozen restaurants serving dishes under the Amish or PA Dutch banner. Mennonite style home made dishes. The large market includes a sliced-to-order deli, special recipe meat shop, Amish and Mennonite local grown fruits and vegetables, made-from-scratch bakery, and on site cannery with jams, jellies, sauces and more. we highly suggest that you try it and you will Today, Chateau Laroche offers tours of both the castle and the grounds. If you have a sweet tooth, then you'll find that Boyd & Wurthmann's is a true treat year round. For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. Hope. Its noodles over mashed potatoes with chicken and gravy and it is delicious! Das Dutch Kitchen is a new one well have to try, though. The Windmill Bake Shop on 501 in South Boston, is Mennonite owned and operated, with Amish and Mennonite workers. (877)852-2888 Belleville, PA 17004 Phone: (717) 667-2185 Toll Free: (800) 982-9755 Reply to Comment Trish in Indiana Well have to do that next time! I was really disappointed. Have you been to any of these stores or markets before? Love the broasted chicken, salad bar and everything else at The Amish Door in Wilmot. Menu items including Spaetzle, a traditional German soup, winzersalat, bratwurst sandwich, or Hackbratentorte meatloaf in crust. *Chalet in the Valley is currently closed. Lunch Buffet - Tuesday-Wednesday 11 am - 7 pm Thursday - Saturday 11 am - 3:30 PM $16.75. Customers rave about their fresh salads and homemade soups. Find your new favorite place to share a meal, catch a show, hit the shops, or spend a night away. You'll find it at 4986 Walnut St, Sugarcreek, OH 44681. Catching up on sports or just holding down a stool are plenty of work while youre visiting. All Rights Reserved. Here, it is used as an adjective, which would render the name as das nederlndische Essenhaus in High German. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. Thank you so much for your help. The Farm at Walnut Creek is located at 4147 Co. Rd. You will receive your first email soon. The interior looks just like grandmas house, and the chicken fried steak cant be beat. Also, Bags IS open on Sundays a rarity in Holmes County. I believe its Mennonite owned and most all the waitstaff were Mennonite and Amish. While there are several shops throughout the state that sell plenty of beautiful Christmas items, theres one shop in particular thats all things Christmas, all the time. d) They yell out Is this yours?, or Restaurants near Amish Country, Ohio on TripAdvisor: Find traveler reviews and candid photos of dining near Amish Country in Ohio, United States. They have a great salad bar! I havent had the pleasure of eating in many Amish restaurants so I would have to say Stoltzfus Farm Restaurant in Intercourse, PA. Their ham loaf is to die for, or perhaps better, to live for. Thank you! What are some cant-miss Amish stores in Ohio? I have not had any food there that I didnt like. What others would you add to this list? What others would you add to this list? Cindys Diner Desserts are out of this world! Best pie around hands down, in my opinion. We are so happy that we found another restaurant owned/run by Amish people. She is an Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W. The Amish tour train no longer operates. Traditional home-cooked meals, cream pies, milk shakes, root beer, ice cream and more available. 8101 State Route 241 Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681 Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant is located at 4819 East Main St., Berlin, OH 44610. The decor is more of the Swiss nature with the clocks and the building is even built to resemble a Swiss chalet. Family Cupboard was my husbands favorite place to eat in Lancaster. I didnt mind because the coconut cream pie was the best! I?ve got to give it to Olde World, although Rebecca?s is a close second! Valerie, She doesnt run a restaurant-but if you were at her house during planting or havesting season you think she did with all the workers eating there at meal time. Hartville Kitchen We would always order the meal family-style and would get large dishes of mashed potatoes, butter homemade egg noodles (YUM! Lunch and dinner offer appetizers, sandwiches, home-style dinners, salads, and homemade desserts. 330 893 4600 The Amish restaurants in Ohio are just the beginning of what youll find in Amish Country. Now I live in Oregon and I get now of it ! but sure is good for the tastebuds. (330)893-2131 It is located at 4653 N State Route 60 NW, McConnelsville, OH 43756. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. It got me thinking about Amish-style eateries. Had to cook em all day to get that flavor, so you had to start with very good-quality noodles, or theyd end up as paste. End of the Commons General Store is Ohios oldest general store, and it can be found, appropriately, in the heart of Amish Country. To learn more, visit their website, Located in the village of Walnut Creek, coming here almost feels like you're visiting a friendly neighbor for the afternoon, rather than eating at a restaurant. In business for decades, the store has grown into a local favorite and for good reason! Seniors meet at the diner for their 5 am coffee and talk through the village news. If youve yet to take a weekend (or week) to explore Ohios Amish Country, you need to make a point to do so; its truly one of the best Ohio day trips. What I do remember was the shoofly pie! Der Dutchman Restaurant and Bakery If your belly is too full for a meal, this is the place to sit at the counter for a piece of pie and a cup of coffee! And, its off the beaten path where we enjoy our Amish journey the best any other new Amish restaurants besides Katies in that area due to elderly parents illness we have been unable to travel to Lancaster area in last 10 or so months. Locals have been visiting the place since it was a grocery store with a dining counter back in the 1940s, but now travelers have caught on to their affordable meals, large serving sizes, and a large variety of pies. The buffalo cauliflower is an appetizer youll drool over, and the Bucking Cheeseburger is so good! Our guide includes over 100 local recommendations on restaurants, attractions, and things to do in the area! Who has recipe for Annapolis Amish market meatloaf? Threshers Dinner @ Amish Acres, Nappanee Indiana With more than 10 years of writing experience and a background in news reporting for Ohio newspapers, she's published pieces in multiple print and online publications. Website, Open May through November, Sweetwater Farm offers itsown farmers market with a full line of fresh fruits and vegetables. Business locations and availability can change. Charlene Edwards/Unsplash. I ask that same question to my husband every year when we go to our annual Khaki Ball (it is a dinner/dance for US Navy Chiefs and their spouses). When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. Mrs. Yoders Kitchen is a long time favorite of locals and tourists alike. When I was growing up, it was hard to find much outside of roast beef & chicken with mashed potatoes- however, Amish Country now offers plenty of unique flavors, plus some old favorites. 4917 State Route 515, Walnut Creek, OH 44687 No matter what you order, youll be impressed. For many reasonsthe old-timey feel to the place, good prices and selection (had a trail bologna sandwich last time), the Amish-style peanut butter spread complimented by robust, bottomless cups of coffee. Im not sure its anything special, but the food is filling and simple, and the restaurants easy to find, once you know its name. Both had The Amish Door Restaurant 1210 Winesburg St. Wilmot, OH 888 264 7436 amishdoor.com Restaurant located at the Amish Door Village in Wilmot, OH. Fill your plate. Berlin, OH If the restaurants are anything like Indiana?s Amish area, it is totally worth a visit! After a day of exploring Ohios Amish area, head home to our inn for a relaxing night in. When I went to survey that link about Essenhaus I could hardly believe my eyes. When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. With more than 10 years of writing experience and a background in news reporting for Ohio newspapers, she's published pieces in multiple print and online publications. * No Self Control We make the most of our moments at mealtime; it's a . Some of their specials include roast beef, prime rib, 3 side dish dinners, soups, pies, ice cream. Mrs.Yoders Kitchen, Mt. We are so happy that we found another restaurant owned/run by Amish people. It may runneth over with our distinctive brew selections. Amish Door is located at 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689. The two young men working were polite and efficient. Everything about Berlin Farmstead is idyllic, from their beautiful outdoor garden to hanging quilts inside their dining area. From seafood to pasta, this place has it all. Raber's is known for homemade bread, sweet rolls with maple or vanilla frosting, and delicious donuts. Middlebury and Wana Cup in Shipshewana. However you choose to spend your time in Amish Country, we know that you will find peace and relaxation when you stay at The White Oak Inn! 6121 South Ave Specializing in authentic Amish Country home-style food for breakfast,lunch and dinner, satisfied diners continue to dish up accolades. Das Dutch Kitchen (As an added bonus, the formerly Amish inn-keepers can give you firsthand insight into the culture and Amish faith.) Believe us, you're going to love this all-you-can-eat Amish buffet In Ohio. Free samples are available throughout the store to try and enjoy before buying! Dont be fooled by the name, Walnut Creek Cheese is a one stop shop for delicious Amish food and food gifts. The Olde Dutch Restaurant Mary Yoders Amish Kitchen It has a real small hometown feel to it, although they are a very busy restaurant. Pet-Friendly Lodging in Amish Country Ohio, Plan Events and Business Retreats in Columbus, Spend a Day at the Best Amish Flea Markets in Ohio, 3 of the Best Places to Find Amish Quilts for Sale in Ohio. One of Boyd & Wurthmann's specialties is homemade pies. 12 Restaurants in Millersburg | 3,895 restaurants available on OpenTable; 13 Walnut Creek Ohio Amish Country Restaurants | The Wallhouse Hotel; 14 A Culinary Heaven in Holmes County | Ohio. 27 Buckeye Street SW, Sugarcreek, OH 44681 Not responsible for changes to the above information. Get ready to relax. Weve done the wine tasting, but never sat down to eat. What was once a grocery store in the 1930s is now a beloved Amish restaurant that locals and visitors can't get enough of. The name is deceiving because this is not just a brewery! Y. ou will find all of the best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and roast beef. dasdutchvillage.com Does anyone know of some place in the Lancaster Pa area of their equal? Best Amish Restaurant near me in Holmes County, Ohio Sort:Recommended Offers Delivery Offers Takeout 1. 330 893 2550 The othermore, American (Traditional)Breakfast & BrunchBuffets$$, I still prefer the larger Amish restaurants, but this was a nice change!more, American (Traditional)BakeriesBreakfast & Brunch$$, There are few truly Amish restaurants in Amish Country, most are tourist traps and cater to themore, It's not a bad Amish restaurant, but not nearly one of my favorites. The Olde Dutch Resturant features old-fashioned cuisine including breakfast, lunch, dinner and desserts menu. Das Dutchman Essenhaus is a curious blend of English and German: Dutchman referring to nationality doesnt exist in German (it would be nederlnder). Lets Dig In. Ohio's oldest general store appropriately sits in the heart of Amish country. I love the work you have done on this..It was a lot of work to visit and enjoy the area. You kind of know one when you see one (taste one? Do try Beachys Country Chalet Restaurant in Sugarcreek OH. Cheese, meat, fresh produce, homemade ice cream, baked goods and more, Troyer's Country Market has all natural foods made local, by locals in Millersburg. Looking for Amish Country Wineries? Very good, fresh food and very enjoyable people to be amongst for a meal. Subscribe to our newsletter to learn more about upcoming events and specials in the area. Pastime seems to capture it. Im all about those cheese samples at Heinis. With so many years of experience and recipes that have passed down from generation to generation, Boyd & Wurthmann have Amish cooking down to an art. 1. Nothing hits the spot quite like down-home cooking paired with heartwarming scenery. I have searched all over & cant seem to find any. Share it in the comments below. Youre about to become an expert. I knew there were many Amish in the area and I was anxious to see the buggys on the roads, as well as the Amish people fascinating! In the Elkhart/Lagrange Counties area, I like Village Inn in Our list of Amish Food and Restaurants can be your guide! A charming restaurant in the basement of the grocery. Funny thing, though, when we were there a big group of about 25 Amish men and women came in and went into the banquet room where the tables were set up in one big half square shape, and as we were leaving the servers were just starting to take in large bowls of noodles, mashed potatoes, gravy, peas, and platters of meat and bread, giving the appearance of some kind of celebration. Ohio has a rather sizable Amish population, and evidence of this charming culture can be seen and experienced all throughout the state. Some of the most popular menu items include the slow roast turkey and homemade stuffing. Amish Door Restaurant Dont know where you are in NY, but Essen Haus in Penn Yan is excellent. 330 482 2236 To learn more, visit their website, From hearty pulled pork sandwiches to mouthwatering brisket, Uncle Beths BBQ in North Lewisburg has it allnot to mention homemade desserts that are to die for. Huge selection, reasonable prices, lots of Amish customers. Old fashioned Amish-cooked dishes such as slow-cooked roast beef or turkey, real mashed potatoes, fresh salads, homemade bread and rolls. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. Where is Reihls Place and Zooks- location?- We have spent time in that area of Pa for the last 4 years and have not discovered them. My Wife unn myself love to eat at Katies Kitchen in Ronks PA Charting a brew trail is an adventure that will carry you across the countryside for savoring and sampling. Ethridge, Tennessee. Were so lucky to live in a state thats full of rolling hillsides and gorgeous views. We keep it casual. In our restaurant, a banquet room, or off-site at your event, you can always enjoy the delicious taste and friendly atmosphere of the Dutch Kitchen! Marketing & Website Design by Q4Launch. This welcoming eatery specializes in country cooking, and their fried chicken is absolutely amazing. I think the name we give it in the states, national pastime, is about right. My name is Justin Quinn and and I hope that you will welcome this idea and not take offense. Theres something special about a midsummer Saturday spent sipping ros on a breezy deck while live music plays. Family owned and operated business, specializing in Amish cooking. Theyre also known for making exceptional apple butter. One of my favorites which I think fits the bill is Boyd and Wurthmanns in Berlin, Ohio. (330)852-4257 I had no idea. This restaurant serves Swiss, Austrian and Amish style meals including schnitzel, bratwurst, fondue, strudel, black forest cake, date nut pudding or apple dumplings. You'll find it at 623 Old State Rd., Clarksville, OH 45113. Thanks for your good work! I have never been to an Amish restaurant. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant offer luxurious privacy and seclusion for your vacation. Amish Home Cooked Meals Bulk Foods & Bakeries Family & Amish Restaurants Foodie Fare Produce & Specialty Foods Cheese & Bites Wineries & Breweries Fresh Food from the Homestead Places to Stay Places to Stay Bed & Breakfasts, Inns Cabins & Cottages Hotels RV Parks & Campgrounds 3-Day Romantic Wine Tour Culture Culture This village is a popular tourist destination for anyone looking to explore Ohio's Amish Country, and it takes pride in its Swiss and German heritage. Looking for the best places to eat when visiting Ohios Amish Country? If you are looking for home-style cooking, I'd say that Dutch Valley offers the best value and the tastiest options. Ive never been to an Amish eatery, just a market stall with a few stools. kidrontownandcountry.com Millersburg, OH It opens for the season in March and is located at 5060 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654. When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. Boyd and Wurthmann is located at 4819 East Main Street, Berlin. we like it best on Tuesday when they serve the Amish Wedding Meal What about Amishdo they eat at these restaurants? Best salad bar , soups , all of it ! Enjoy comfort food staples like fried chicken, meat loaf, and mashed potatoes. The Amish Door Restaurant You'll find Dutch Kitchen in this restored farmhouse, which was built in 1858. Best amish restaurant near me in Mansfield, Ohio Sort:Recommended Price Offers Delivery Offers Takeout Good for Kids Good for Dinner Accepts Credit Cards 1. PA Dutch style food including buttermilk hotcakes, slices of fried mush with sausage gravy or syrup, warm biscuits topped with homemade sausage gravy, smoked ham, pork and sauerkraut with side dishes such as mashed potatoes, homemade egg noodles, creamed corn or green beans and more. Guests can also choose to have a full family sized Amish style meal prepared instead of individual orders. Wilmot, OH https://whiteoakinn.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/logo.jpg, Below you will find a comprehensive guide to the best. This is a fun place to eat with a friend, the dining room is ample and the service is quick enough to meet on a lunch break. Take a trip to Henry County and experience it for yourself. Thanks for any info. We also loved all the places everyone has already named for Holmes/Wayne Counties in Ohio, but does anyone know of any others not mentioned yet? Good Sandwiches and soup at lunchtime, with excellent baked goods. To learn more, visit their website here. Living in the Cleveland OH area, we go to Holmes/Wayne County Amish country several times a year. Check out these hotels in Walnut Creek, Ohio. As soon as you step inside, your mouth will start watering uncontrollably. And Im glad you enjoyed it Valerie. My favorite at Bags is the Chicken Parmesan Sandwich on a pretzel bun (pictured below), while my husband adores the Jalapeno Burger. We can't get enough of this, This charming bed and breakfast is another picture perfect place to stay while you're exploring the area. Walnut Creek Ohio Sugarcreek Ohio Middlebury Indiana Sarasota Florida Bellville Ohio Plain City Ohio Berlin Ohio Theater East Main Kitchen offers a kids menu and plenty of seating for families. Share your thoughts with us in the comments below. We also always hit Heini?s Cheese Chalet for cheese & fudge and Kauffmans Country Bakery for bread in Millersburg. But Im with you on Mrs. Yoders in Mt. That is why I asked. Worth a stop! Marcus Yoder, Hi Erik! Let us know! Der Dutchman 340, and the Dutch-Way Restaurant/Markets in Gap and Myerstown. Traditional breakfast favorites are served at the break of dawn along with your choice of donuts, fritters, and cinnamon rolls. Anna Maes, Millbank, Ontario Canada These are both on the National Road and the Casselman Bridge is right by the Penn Alps. April is the Ohio staff writer for Only in Your State. Looking for a Spooky Adventure? 5060 State Route 557 However you choose to spend your time in Amish Country, we know that you will find peace and relaxation when you stay at The White Oak Inn! A.J. But yes, I didnt add it to the list because I havent been there since high school. Sip & savor. Specializes in Amish and German style cuisine along with American flavors. The only thing Amish about it was the name. Enjoy good food with friends & family. But I definitely visit the more conventional places as well. Re: Best Amish Restaurant in and around town. Watch the firelight flicker on the cathedral ceiling while you relax in the oversized Whirlpool tub for two, or simply look at the stars through the picture window facing out into the woods. Canal Tavern of Zoar He went for every meal when we were in the area. Its also about sinking into the slowed speed of the country, about appreciating the moment instead of living for the minute. 6050 OH-515, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA 10. There were a couple other things we tried there, but now we just go and share the appetizer. Mrs Yoders Kitchen, 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, USA, Enjoy authentic Swiss, Austrian, and American cuisine in the heart of Holmes County at, Chalet In The Valley Restaurant, 5060 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA. We also enjoy Shady Maple, as well as Yoders and Family Cupboard, All excellent Amish food. Weve got the broasted chicken and the green beans steaming. 330 893 2717 Well, weve got grapes and hops, and we know how to use them. In the bakery youll find pastries, pies, cookies, donuts, fudge, cakes, breads, and so much more! Millersburg, the puppy mill capital of Ohio. It is 50% of the reason I am going home for Thanksgivinglol. What makes it good? Come and experience one of the best Amish restaurants in Ohio! Our famous buffet is best known for the perfectly crispy, Amish fried chicken. With rows and rows of fabric and quilting supplies, the possibilities at, Country Fabrics, 6142 Ganges-Five Points Rd, Shiloh, OH 44878, USA, Inside, you'll be mesmerized by all the sweets and the smell of what's cooking will make you want to stay awhile. The menu, of course, is the place to start. This little restaurant will whisk you back to a simpler time. The young man that took my order wiped the counter down, washed his hands and put on gloves before taking my order. Website, Der Dutchman Restaurant in Walnut Creek fills your taste for Amish favorite foods serving breakfast, lunch and dinner with buffet and salad bar. Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen features a hearty buffet, delicious homemade pies and an at-home atmosphere we know you'll love. Thank you! Excellent list Marie and nice to see a Canadian entry. And the meat was even MORE slow-cooked, because she always started with canned meat. Rach unn Ivan. Gather your strength from sharing the slow-cooked goodness and the fresh-made friendships. Visiting Millersburg for the day? This interactive farm features more than 500 animals, including a beautiful herd of giraffes. DIE is also used for plural, so die amische = the Amish. Someone mentioned these two names of restaurants in Lancaster County. During the tour, youll learn all about the castle and its eccentric builder, making for one of the most unique Ohio day trips. I kind of forgot about Breitenbach! If your in the Big Valley area of Central PA you have to stop by A.J. If youre a lifelong Ohioan, then you know that some of the states best restaurants are hiding in rural Ohio. At these local joints, the menu is unpredictable, but always tasty, and the price is, well, literally impossible to beat. I have tried several others as I work in Holmes County sometimes, and this is still my favorite. oldedutch.com April is the Ohio staff writer for Only in Your State. To learn more, visit their website, This award-winning southeast Ohio barbecue joint features a diverse menu, from Louisiana Crab Cakes to slow cooked ribs and pulled pork. info@whiteoakinn.com. Id love to visit Olde World Bakery & Bistro! A couple of decades ago, Sugarcreek was the major shopping and dining area in Amish Country. Its called Hometown Kitchen and is located behind Fishers Fabric & Housewares store ( a really neat place, as well ) on Route 896 in Bart/Georgetown. I would love to head back to Amish country again, for the great food and the charming culture. Stretched across multiple counties and small rural towns in east-central Ohio, youll find one of the states most heartwarming attractions: Amish Country. Family owned and operated since 1935, Heinis Cheese Chalet offers Bunker Hill Cheese and more made from 100% local dairy. Amish homemade style food such as roastedchicken, roast beef, ham, mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, corn, green beans, noodles, salad bar, Amish casserole and much more. It's located at 6262 OH 245, North Lewisburg, OH 43060. Amish Door Village started humbly as a small 48 seat restaurant and now includes the huge Amish Door Restaurant (above) as well as a bakery, market, gift shop and country inn all in one location. DIE is feminine, so die Kche = the kitchen. Amish Door is located at 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH, 44689. Amish Country Donuts Donut Shops Coffee Shops Restaurants (15) Website (330) 852-5214 522 Dover Rd NE Sugarcreek, OH 44681 2. * Gluttony To learn more, visit their website, Set in an oversized Amish style home that has a seating capacity of 450, this restaurant is located in Wilmont. Free shipping for many products! Serving PA Dutch traditional food including roast turkey, chicken and special-recipe noodles, mashed potatoes, homemade soups, fresh baked breads and muffins. Best in Holmes Co OH with most Amish attending, Mrs. Millers Mt. Hope, Ohio, where youll often see many homegrown and visiting Plain folks. Restaurant a couple of miles north of Loogootee. For even more fantastic fare, visit The Olde Dutch Restaurant in Logan. Im sure there are others as there are a lot of Amish settlements in NY State now. While visiting Holmes County and surrounds, youll find a plethora of baked goods and full dinners. Scripps School of Journalism. Also I would say that Chalet In The Valley is more Swiss/German than Amish. Very good, fresh food and very enjoyable people to be amongst for a meal. 72 Barrville Rd. The Blue Gate Restaurant and Bakery. Im using the term Amish restaurant very broadly, and would include eateries advertising themselves as PA Dutch, Amish-style, etc. 4819 East Main Street, Berlin, OH 44610 Mrs Yoders Kitchen, 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, USA 3.